Halloween horror thug who stabbed child with scissors goes free despite catalog of violence

The court heard Duncan pulled a baseball bat on two neighbors after hearing them make death threats against him from the common area outside his home. Admitted having an offensive weapon in Bute Drive. perthOn July 5, 2024.

Admitted that he violated the rules court curfew on June 15, 2021 – just four days after it was implemented. He also confessed to a similar crime between January 4 and 6, 2023.

Duncan admitted to smashing two cars with a hammer in Carnegie Place. perthHe stated that he behaved in a threatening manner by shouting aggressively and making racist statements on May 26, 2024, and on September 27.

Sheriff Wood told Duncan: “You are a constant source of frustration to me. “As you were involved in a rather ugly incident in October 2020, we have made you aware that this behavior will not be tolerated.

“I thought close contact with the detainee might soften your behaviour. You have been free on bail ever since. I will not send you anywhere else. prison Today.

“You’re only 20 years old. You’ve been in the justice system for a while now and it’s time you started showing some results. There’s been a lot of investment and people getting involved to help you through the difficult times you’re going through. It’s time to help yourself and stop going through any more trouble.”

“None of your crimes show that you are a good member of society rather than a hang-on. You need to start making better choices, or I will inevitably send you there.” prison.

The defendant then thanked sheriff Halloween admonished him for the scissors attack.

The victim, who was attacked while trying to protect other children from Duncan’s attacks, was stabbed to the bone and underwent emergency surgery after losing 250ml of blood.

Duncan left his victim for dead after biting her and repeatedly stabbing her with scissors in the leg, causing serious injuries. Duncan had downed “any number” of tonic wine bottles before attacking several schoolchildren on an island in the River Tay. perth.

Duncan admitted to repeatedly striking a 15-year-old boy in the face on Moncrieffe Island in 2022. perth On October 31, 2020.

He admitted to behaving in a threatening or abusive manner by shouting, swearing and threatening several young people by saying he had a knife. He admitted acting in concert with another 15-year-old boy by attacking him by repeatedly punching him in the head.

And Duncan eventually admitted that he attacked a third boy, a 15-year-old boy, while he was acting out with someone else, leaving him severely injured and permanently disfigured. He admitted punching her in the head and body, struggling with her, causing her to fall to the ground, biting her face, and striking her body repeatedly with scissors.

Fiscal depute Joanne Ritchie said: court A number of unprovoked incidents occurred, including threatening to kill girls who refused to give him alcohol.

The stabbed boy bravely intervened to stop Duncan from attacking another child, punching Duncan in the nose and knocking him to the ground.

“The defendant laid the child on the ground and bit him on the cheek. The child continued to punch him. The fight lasted several minutes. A witness was heard saying ‘he was stabbed’. The child was lying on the ground and the defendant repeatedly hit him in the face, body and legs.

“The defendant had something in his hand. The defendant repeatedly hit his body and leg. Witnesses observed the defendant with scissors. The child was lying on the ground with pain in his face, body and legs. They helped him and applied pressure to the wound.”

He told the court the knife penetrated into his thigh bone and the boy had to undergo emergency surgery after being taken to Ninewells Hospital. Dundee. Sheriff William Wood placed Duncan in the Right Path program for young offenders at this stage. The same court I heard today that Duncan completed 274 hours of unpaid work on the project.

The sheriff said: “The events of 31 October 2020 were clearly appalling. Here you were attacking people completely out of control. You put yourself in a situation where you didn’t know what you were doing. “If you were over 18 I would almost certainly have detained you.

“You can’t go around stabbing people. If you take your age into account, you get a chance to see how things work in society.”

In an earlier groundbreaking case, Duncan was a 15-year-old boy with a special situation. courtroom Until his trial for “psychological domestic violence”.

Duncan’s name could not be released at the time because he was the youngest person to be prosecuted under the new law, which aims to target psychological attacks. tyranny in relationships.

Don’t miss the latest news from Scotland and beyond. Sign up for our daily newsletter.